Rival Bookstore Sues WVU Bookstore for $2 Million Monopoly
A bookstore that serves the students of West Virginia University (WVU) has sued the university and Barnes & Noble College Booksellers, Inc. for monopolizing the textbook sales market in the WVU area.
The Book Exchange filed the suit on June 8, claiming that WVUâ€™s practice of withholding a portion of studentsâ€™ financial aid money for use specifically at school bookstores limits the choices students have for purchasing cheap textbooks. The practice of withholding financial aid money began in August 2005, right before a lease contract between WVU stores and Barnes & Noble College Booksellers, Inc. was renewed for a second five-year term in 2006.
According to the lawsuit, WVU sent an email to its students on Dec. 13, 2005 informing them that â€œan amount up to $500 has been reserved on account at the bookstore.â€ Students that did not want the bookstore to take that money were to remove themselves from the program by Dec. 16. Students who did not remove themselves were unable to spend a portion of their financial aid money on textbooks from The Book Exchange or any other textbook-purchasing alternative.
In the lawsuit, The Book Exchange accuses WVU of violating West Virginia Code by redirecting studentsâ€™ financial aid money to the campus bookstore and preventing them from obtaining the textbooks at lower-cost alternatives like The Book Exchange. The suit also alleges that the automatic withholding of funds was intended to monopolize the market of selling textbooks to financial aid students.
The Book Exchange is seeking more than $2 million dollars from the defendants for lost revenue and punitive damages.
Bailey, Cara. “Bookstore sues WVU for monopoly, seeks $2 million.” The West Virginia Record 15 June 2007. 19 June 2007. http://www.wvrecord.com/news/196757-bookstore-sues-wvu-for-monopoly-seeks-2-million